The global cocoa and coffee industries are at a critical juncture. Prices for these essential commodities have surged to unprecedented levels, driven by the intensifying impacts of climate change and the fragility of supply chains. As costs rise, producers and manufacturers are turning to alternative ingredients and innovative technologies to maintain supply and address growing demand.
Prices Soaring Amid Climate Pressures
Cocoa prices, traditionally stable between $2,000 and $3,000 (€1,920-€2,880) per tonne, have skyrocketed to more than €10,000 in recent months. Arabica coffee, the most widely consumed variety, has seen futures rise by nearly 70% in 2023, reaching €3.2 per pound. These price hikes are largely attributed to worsening climate conditions in major producing regions like Ghana, Ivory Coast, and Brazil. Droughts, erratic weather patterns, and pest infestations have significantly reduced yields, creating a supply crunch that reverberates throughout global markets.
The European Union, one of the largest importers of cocoa and coffee, is feeling the effects acutely. With these commodities forming the backbone of the region’s confectionery and beverage sectors, rising prices are pushing production costs higher, ultimately passing the burden onto consumers.
At the same time, demand continues to grow. Coffee consumption alone, currently valued at €46 billion annually, is projected to triple by 2050, according to Conservation International. Coupled with cocoa’s central role in the €122 billion global confectionery market, the pressure on producers is mounting. This dual challenge of surging demand and dwindling supply has accelerated efforts to find sustainable and cost-effective alternatives.
Cocoa and Coffee Alternatives Gain Traction
In response to these market pressures, companies are increasingly looking at alternatives to traditional cocoa and coffee. In Europe, innovations in cocoa-free chocolate and coffee substitutes are taking shape, driven by a need to lower costs and secure more sustainable production methods.
German company Planet A Foods with its Choviva brand, for example, has become a leader in cocoa substitutes, producing 2,000 tonnes annually from sunflower seeds and roasted dates. To meet rising demand, the company recently closed a €30 million funding round to expand its operations, aiming to position itself as a global supplier.
In France, Vallée Torréfaction has pioneered cocoa-free chocolate using roasted malted barley powder. While the product differs slightly in taste from traditional chocolate, it offers a cost-effective and versatile alternative for baked goods and confections. Vallée Torréfaction’s founder, Paul Vallée, predicts that cocoa-based chocolate will increasingly become a luxury item, reserved for high-end products, as its cost continues to rise.
Beyond cocoa, the market for coffee substitutes is also growing. Alternatives made from barley and other grains are gaining traction in Europe, where they have long been used as caffeine-free options. This market, valued at €13.6 billion in 2023, is expected to grow by 4.7% annually through 2032, reflecting both consumer interest and industry investment in non-traditional coffee products.
Researchers at Finland’s VTT Technical Research Centre have pioneered lab-grown coffee using cellular agriculture. By cultivating coffee cells in bioreactors, this method could significantly reduce the environmental toll of traditional coffee farming, including deforestation and water overuse.
Israeli biotechnology firm Pluri Inc. has joined the movement, developing cultivated coffee through advanced cell multiplication technologies. This process could save substantial natural resources and reduce the land footprint of coffee production, aligning with global sustainability goals.
Big Players Eye Alternatives
The growing interest in alternatives isn’t limited to startups. Major industry players are actively exploring and investing in new technologies. Mondelez International, known for brands like Cadbury and Toblerone, has made a strategic investment in Israeli startup Celleste Bio. Using cell-culture technology, the startup produces cocoa-free chocolate, aiming to address long-term supply chain vulnerabilities. The $4.5 million investment, led by Mondelez’s SnackFutures venture arm, underscores the company’s commitment to innovative solutions.
In the U.S., Voyage Foods has emerged as a prominent player in the cocoa alternative market. The California-based company has developed cocoa-free chocolate and nut-free spreads, designed to replicate the taste and texture of traditional products. Its recent partnership with agricultural giant Cargill highlights the growing collaboration between startups and established firms. Cargill, now the exclusive B2B distributor for Voyage Foods, plans to integrate these alternatives into a range of products, from confectionery to baked goods.
Meanwhile, Sparkalis, the corporate venture arm of Belgian bakery and chocolate giant Puratos, has invested in California Cultured. This plant-cell culture startup specializes in producing cocoa and other botanicals under controlled conditions. Sparkalis views this partnership as a critical step toward future-proofing the cocoa supply chain and addressing the widening gap between supply and demand.
The Future of Cocoa and Coffee
As climate change continues to disrupt traditional cocoa and coffee farming, the need for alternatives is becoming increasingly urgent. While cocoa-based chocolate and coffee are likely to remain staples in the short term, their rising costs and environmental toll could push them into the realm of luxury goods. Innovations in substitutes, from cereal-based products to lab-grown options, offer a viable path forward for an industry under pressure.
The shift toward alternatives also reflects broader consumer trends. Shoppers are increasingly prioritizing sustainability and ethical sourcing, prompting companies to rethink their supply chains and product portfolios. For producers, retailers, and investors, the move toward alternatives isn’t just a matter of cost—it’s a strategy for long-term survival in an evolving market.
Though challenges remain in scaling these new technologies and achieving mass-market appeal, the growing wave of investments and partnerships signals a significant transformation in the global cocoa and coffee industries. The question is not if these alternatives will gain traction, but how quickly they will become integral to the way we consume two of the world’s most beloved products.
Comments